guidelines

osteoporosis (fragility fracture risk assessment + pragmatic treatment pathways)

nice-based fracture risk assessment using frax/qfracture and dxa, with practical uk-style treatment options (bisphosphonates and referral decisions) clinicians can action.

last reviewed: 2026-02-13
based on: NICE CG146 (published 08 Aug 2012; last updated 07 Feb 2017; last reviewed 24 Oct 2024, update in progress) + NICE TA464 (bisphosphonates; last updated 08 Jul 2019)

Who to assess and how (NICE CG146)

  • Assess fracture risk in: all women ≥65, all men ≥75, and younger adults with risk factors (prior fragility fracture, oral/systemic glucocorticoids, falls history, low BMI, smoking, alcohol >14 units/week, secondary osteoporosis).
  • Do not routinely assess under-50s unless major risk factors (e.g., prior fragility fracture or prolonged high-dose glucocorticoids).
  • Use FRAX or QFracture (within age ranges) to estimate 10-year absolute fracture risk. FRAX: 40–90 (with or without BMD). QFracture: 30–84 (BMD not incorporated).
  • DXA: do not use DXA routinely without prior FRAX/QFracture. Consider DXA when risk is around the local intervention threshold and you want to re-classify by adding BMD (FRAX + BMD).

Pragmatic treatment approach (UK primary care style)

Note: CG146 covers risk assessment; medication choices are typically guided by local thresholds and NICE technology appraisals (e.g. TA464 for bisphosphonates). Use your local formulary/pathway for intervention thresholds.

  • Usually treat without delay if there is a low-trauma (fragility) hip or vertebral fracture (plus falls prevention and secondary causes screen).
  • Typical first-line for most: an oral bisphosphonate if suitable (e.g. alendronic acid 70 mg once weekly), with counselling on administration (full glass of water, upright 30 minutes, empty stomach).
  • Alternatives if intolerance/contraindications: risedronate 35 mg weekly, ibandronate 150 mg monthly, or IV options / denosumab via specialist pathway (ensure a “stop plan” for denosumab to avoid rebound vertebral fractures).
  • Calcium/vitamin D: ensure dietary calcium and correct vitamin D deficiency; supplement where indicated (particularly if prescribing antiresorptives and intake is low).

Work-up and referral triggers

  • Secondary causes: check calcium, vitamin D, renal function, LFTs, TFTs, coeliac screen when appropriate; review steroids and endocrine contributors.
  • Renal function: oral bisphosphonates are usually avoided in significant renal impairment (follow product SPC/local formulary).
  • Specialist referral if: very high fracture risk / multiple fractures, suspected vertebral fractures needing imaging and onward care, complex secondary osteoporosis, treatment failure, or if parenteral/anabolic therapy is being considered.
  • Review horizon: reassess adherence and tolerability after initiation; many pathways consider a “drug holiday” after 5 years of oral bisphosphonate in lower-risk patients (per local protocol).

Frequently asked questions

FRAX or QFracture — which should I use?
NICE CG146 supports either. Use the tool embedded in your local pathway. FRAX can incorporate BMD (useful after DXA) while QFracture does not.
When should I order DXA?
After an initial FRAX/QFracture estimate, if the patient’s calculated risk sits around the local intervention threshold and adding BMD might change your decision.
Do I need to treat immediately after a fragility fracture?
In many pathways, yes—particularly after hip or vertebral fracture—while you also address falls risk, vitamin D status, and secondary causes. Use local thresholds and the relevant NICE technology appraisals for drug selection.

Transparency

This page is an educational, clinician-written summary of publicly available NICE guidance intended for trained healthcare professionals. It uses original wording (not copied text) and should be used alongside the full NICE source, local pathways, and clinical judgement. Doses provided are for general reference; always check the BNF/SPC.