SCA Revision is the incumbent — 350+ expert-written cases, 70+ consultation videos with marking breakdowns, group revision via QR code, and 9,000+ users since the CSA era. It is the benchmark SCA platform. £11.99-15.99/month.
MedTutor AI is the challenger — 100 voice-based AI patient simulations across 28 specialties, instant three-domain feedback, and a Foundation plan (£195) with 100 credits and GP trainer reviews. 750+ users. The entire product is the AI patient experience.
Head-to-Head
Content volume: SCA Revision wins — 350+ cases vs 100. If you want maximum case exposure, SCA Revision provides 3.5x more scenarios.
Practice realism: MedTutor wins — native voice simulation with real-time AI patient interaction is more immersive than reading a written case. SCA Revision added AI patients via SCARevision.ai (ElevenLabs/Deepgram/ChatGPT), but they feel supplementary rather than core.
Video content: SCA Revision only — 70+ consultation videos with marking breakdowns. No equivalent on MedTutor. Watching someone else consult and seeing it marked is uniquely valuable.
Group revision: SCA Revision only — QR-code group feature for remote three-person practice. MedTutor is solo.
Pricing: SCA Revision £11.99/month flat subscription. MedTutor credit-based (~£10/3 scenarios) or £195 Foundation plan. For high-volume practice, SCA Revision is more cost-effective.
Social proof: SCA Revision claims 9,000+ users. MedTutor claims 750+.
Recommendation
Use SCA Revision for case breadth and consultation videos. Use MedTutor for solo voice practice when you cannot access a study partner. Many trainees use both — SCA Revision for studying cases and MedTutor for practising them.
Where iatroX Fits
Both focus on SCA consultation skills. Neither provides systematic clinical knowledge revision. Pair either with iatroX's free adaptive quiz to ensure your knowledge base matches your consultation technique.